Hotel Operating DiagnosisProfessional Insights

Hotel Food and Beverage Menus: Which Category of Dishes Should Go First?

Author: MarvelBros C&TPublished: 2026-11-128 min read

Key Takeaway

When trimming a hotel food and beverage menu, cut first the category of dishes with low peak-period contribution whose dedicated ingredients are often wasted. The article gives a table that sorts dishes into four categories by peak contribution and waste, how to calculate peak contribution and dedicated ingredient waste, the division of authority under three operating models, the commitments to check and the order of removal before cutting, and the success criteria and stop conditions for a trial over one stocktaking cycle.

Reviewed by the MarvelBros C&T professional team

When trimming a hotel food and beverage menu, cut first the category of dishes with low peak-period contribution whose dedicated ingredients are often wasted. Dishes that meet only one of these conditions are handled differently: those with low peak contribution but ingredients shared with other dishes can stay for now; those that sell at peak but have high waste should first have their recipe and prep changed, with no rush to remove them.

Menus usually grow long one dish at a time: the brand launches a new item, a regular orders something once, a banquet asks for a dish. The most common way to trim is to cross off the few dishes that sell least. Selling little does not in itself decide whether a dish stays or goes; what decides which dishes go first is whether a dish earns money for the kitchen at its busiest times, and whether its ingredients keep spoiling in the store.

Why can't you look only at sales volume and gross profit?

The common method of menu analysis is called menu engineering. Sheryl E. Kimes, a professor at the Cornell University School of Hotel Administration, described this approach in a 2004 report for the university's Center for Hospitality Research: calculate the contribution margin (selling price less the cost) and the number sold for each dish, plot them on a graph, and divide the dishes into four categories according to whether each figure is above average; the report suggests treating the two high-volume categories as candidates for price increases, and notes that restaurants using the method generally review the results every month. In its menu engineering section, the report discusses pricing.

This article's judgment is that these two measures miss two things. The first is timing: two dishes with the same daily sales, one concentrated at the dinner peak and the other spread across the afternoon, mean completely different things to the kitchen. The second is waste: the unit contribution margin is usually based on the ingredient cost in the standard recipe, and the portion that spoils and is thrown away is not included. The 12th Revised Edition of USALI (the Uniform System of Accounts for the Lodging Industry) was published in July 2024 and has been effective since January 1, 2026, but its full text must be purchased and could not be read for this article, so the 11th Revised Edition is used as the basis. The 11th Revised Edition of USALI states that spoilage, waste and spillage are included in Cost of Food Sales. This waste lands in the restaurant's total food cost and cannot be assigned to any one dish, so it has to be attributed separately.

Which table should the owner use to classify dishes?

First divide the dishes into four categories. High and low are judged against the average for similar dishes on the same menu at the hotel. The table is best filled in by the executive chef and finance together; the sections that follow explain how the two measures are calculated.

CategoryPeak contributionWasteWhat to do
Cut firstLowHighStop buying dedicated ingredients; remove once sold out
Change the methodHighHighAdjust prep batch sizes, portions or ingredients, then observe
Keep for nowLowLowNo rush to remove; look again at the next review
KeepHighLowLeave unchanged as a peak mainstay

Dishes in the change-the-method category are not removed in a hurry because they sell at peak, and removing them would cut revenue directly. You can first reduce the size of each prep batch, replace dedicated ingredients with ones shared with other dishes, or add smaller portions. Article 7 of the Anti-Food Waste Law of the People's Republic of China (a Chinese law) requires catering service operators to set quantities and portion sizes reasonably and to offer choices of different sizes such as small portions; those providing group dining services must build the idea of preventing food waste into menu design. After the change, observe for another cycle; if waste does not come down, move the dish into the cut-first category.

Who makes the call depends on how the hotel is operated. At a managed hotel, menu changes are usually proposed by the operator's food and beverage manager; before approving, the owner can ask to see this classification table and the two measures for each dish proposed for removal, and approval authority is governed by the management agreement. At a franchised hotel, first check whether the brand requires certain core dishes or signature dishes to be kept; removing any of these requires the brand's consent first. If the owner operates the franchised hotel, the general manager leads; if a management company has been hired, treat it as a managed hotel. At an unbranded owner-operated hotel there is no external menu standard: the executive chef proposes, the general manager and the owner confirm, and the classification results and reasons are kept on file so that the next review has a basis for comparison.

How do you calculate peak contribution for a hotel food and beverage menu?

Peak means the period when the hotel's kitchen or seating is under the most pressure. It differs from hotel to hotel and can be identified from hourly order counts and ticket times in the point-of-sale (POS) system. A hotel without hourly records can start by using its busiest meal period instead, record it for several weeks in a row, and then gradually narrow it down to the hour. The peak should be defined by the hotel's bottleneck: if the kitchen fills up first, look at ticket times; if seating fills up first, look at table turns and waiting. Peak contribution is a dish's sales during the peak multiplied by its unit contribution margin. Also look at how much time it ties up at key stations during the peak: if a dish occupies a wok or an oven for a long time, one extra portion at peak may push out several others. To gauge the time tied up, sample a few plates at each station during the peak, recording the start and finish times of each; a rough range is enough.

Work it through with a set of hypothetical figures. In a four-week stocktaking cycle, Dish A sells 12 portions at peak with a unit contribution margin of RMB 40, for a peak contribution of RMB 480; it uses one dedicated ingredient, and RMB 900 worth of that ingredient is thrown away during the cycle. Dish B sells 30 portions at peak with a unit contribution margin of RMB 35, for a peak contribution of RMB 1,050; all its ingredients are shared with other dishes, and only RMB 100 of waste is attributed to it. Classified by the average for similar dishes described earlier, Dish A has low peak contribution and high waste, so it belongs in the cut-first category; Dish B has high peak contribution and low waste and should be kept.

Both sides deserve a second look. If Dish A sells well at afternoon tea or late-night supper, consider putting it only on that period's menu rather than removing it all day; if Dish B often holds up the delivery of a whole table's dishes at peak, its peak contribution should be discounted. These figures only demonstrate the method and do not represent the actual margin or waste of any dish.

First agree which figure to use for the unit contribution margin. Only when it is the selling price minus the standard recipe ingredient cost can dishes be compared with one another; dishes in set menus and banquets have no separate selling price, so this article's judgment is to leave them out at first and look at them after the a la carte menu has been classified.

How is waste attributed to a single dish?

First divide ingredients into two kinds. Ingredients used by only one dish are dedicated ingredients; those used by several dishes are shared ingredients. Purchases and waste of dedicated ingredients can be attributed in full to that dish; waste of shared ingredients is hard to split among dishes, and this article's judgment is that it need not be forced apart and can stay in total waste. Dishes with many dedicated ingredients and low sales turn over slowly and easily pass their expiry dates, which is where waste is most concentrated. Fresh, live and short-shelf-life dedicated ingredients matter most; frozen products turn over slowly and spoil less, and mainly tie up inventory funds and cold storage space. One more kind is easily missed: semi-finished items prepared in advance so that the peak runs faster, which are thrown away when unsold at their time limit; these too should be attributed to the corresponding dishes as dedicated ingredients.

Where the waste figures come from depends on whether the hotel records waste stage by stage. How to locate waste across purchasing, receiving, preparation and the buffet counter is covered in a separate article; here, only three figures for dedicated ingredients are needed: purchase quantities, waste quantities and month-end stocktakes.

Before cutting, which commitments should be checked, and in what order should dishes be removed?

Before removing a dish, check three kinds of commitments: dishes the brand standards require to be kept; dishes written into set menus, banquet menus and agreements already sold; and options kept for vegetarian, allergy and other dietary needs. For the first two, contracts must be dealt with or consent obtained before removal; for the last, an alternative must be kept even if numbers are small.

The order of removal also matters. First stop buying the dedicated ingredients, use up the stock, and mark the dish on the menu as available while stocks last; once the stock is used up, remove it at the same time from printed menus, online ordering and booking platforms. Crossing a dish off without dealing with its stock turns the remaining dedicated ingredients into new waste.

How do you trial it first, and when do you stop?

First trial it in one restaurant or one production area for a full stocktaking cycle. Before the trial, the executive chef, the restaurant manager and finance should write down the success criteria and stop conditions, for example how far waste spending on dedicated ingredients must fall to count as effective, and how much fluctuation in peak average spend per table and ticket times counts as normal. Set the specific values from the hotel's records for previous cycles, write them into the trial record, and do not change them after the trial. Each measure has its limits: a fall in waste spending shows that less of the dedicated ingredients was thrown away, but not whether guests are satisfied; average spend per table varies with the guest mix and holidays, so it should be read alongside the guest mix for the same period.

In any of the following cases, restore the removed dish or stop extending the change: guests ask for the dish by name, or reviews mention it repeatedly; the fall in peak average spend per table goes beyond the range written down in advance; or contract clients or banquet clients insist that it be kept. If the results hold up, handle the next batch of cut-first dishes in the same order.

What does this method not cover?

It decides only which category goes first, not how many dishes the menu should keep, and it does not deal with pricing or new dish development. In restaurants whose seats and kitchen are never full at any time of year, there is little difference between peak and normal times, and this article's judgment is that whole-day contribution can be used in place of peak contribution, while waste is still calculated as before. Adding or removing items on the breakfast buffet is discussed in an earlier article on this site about breakfast waste; which stage waste occurs in should be checked stage by stage using the method in the separate article. This article does not cover outsourcing the entire kitchen. Whether food can still be used is always decided by food safety requirements. MarvelBros C&T can help align menu classification with a hotel's food cost reports.

Further Reading

Hotel Breakfast Waste: Reduce the Menu or Adjust Replenishment? https://www.marvelbros.com/en/lean/article/hotel-breakfast-waste-menu-replenishment-2026-10-13

July Occupancy Rebounded. Why Is Hotel F&B Revenue Still Under Pressure? https://www.marvelbros.com/en/lean/article/july-occupancy-rebounded-hotel-fnb-revenue-pressure-2026-08-28

References

Kimes, S. E. (2004). Restaurant Revenue Management. CHR Reports, Vol. 4, No. 2. Cornell University Center for Hospitality Research. (page 19) https://hdl.handle.net/1813/71185

HFTP: Uniform System of Accounts for the Lodging Industry, Eleventh Revised Edition, Food and Beverage (Schedule 2): Cost of Food Sales (printed page 30). https://www.hftp.org/downloads/documents/usali/usali-659-11-digital.pdf

Anti-Food Waste Law of the People's Republic of China (a Chinese law; adopted April 29, 2021), Article 7. http://www.npc.gov.cn/npc/c2/c30834/202104/t20210429_311300.html

Further reading

Explore these related questions

Discuss your hotel

Lots of activity, but unstable results?

Start with the project stage and the hardest question to answer, then decide whether a further conversation is useful.

Does this article relate to your hotel?

Tell us your project stage and the question you find hardest to answer. The article reference will accompany your enquiry.

Ask about this article
MarvelBros C&T

All rights reserved. Please credit MarvelBros C&T when sharing.