Why Shouldn’t Checkout and Stayover Rooms Count as the Same Workload?
The two types of rooms require different cleaning tasks and have different conditions for handing the room over. Room attendant scheduling should therefore first identify the work according to the hotel’s room types, cleaning categories and actual working conditions, and then allocate rooms. The same number of rooms does not necessarily mean the same workload, and differences in speed should not initially be attributed to employees.
In a 2021 study of a single hotel in Spain, Aguilar-Escobar et al. classified room cleaning as checkout, stayover, or stayover with changes, meaning a linen change. The study found that room type and cleaning category were associated with cleaning time within this sample. It cannot tell another hotel how many rooms each person should be assigned, but it does suggest to managers that room count is not a complete measure of workload.
Why Checkout and Stayover Rooms Should Not Be Measured Against the Same Yardstick
The study hotel defined the three cleaning categories differently. Checkout cleaning takes place after a guest has departed and prepares the room for the next new guest. Stayover cleaning serves guests who will continue to use the same room that day. Stayover with changes also involves changing the bed linen. Other hotels may not use the same service categories, but before assigning the work, they still need to establish what tasks each room in the batch requires.
The difference between checkout and stayover rooms is therefore not a matter of attaching a fixed time label to each category. It depends on who will use the room next, what tasks must actually be completed, and when the room can be entered. When calculating the workload for room cleaning, the planned categories listed early that morning cannot simply be treated as the actual work performed during the day.
This study was conducted at a four-star hotel with 74 rooms. It observed 74 cleaning sessions involving a total of 8 employees: 36 checkouts, 35 stayovers, and 3 stayovers with changes. The study recorded cleaning tasks inside the rooms and some work outside the rooms directly related to cleaning. It explicitly excluded other work performed by the employees and did not assess cleaning quality. With only 3 observations of stayovers with changes, this category is particularly unsuitable for setting a separate weighting.
These boundaries determine how the paper can be used. It can help identify tasks that a hotel may have overlooked. Its time figures should not be copied as individual quotas, nor should its limited sample be used to conclude that training is ineffective, that quality has declined, or that staffing can be reduced. Matters not measured during the observations should not be written into the schedule as if they were established conclusions.
How Room Attendant Scheduling Can Reveal Work Beyond Room Counts
Between a room being scheduled for cleaning and its completion for handover, the planned category may change, guests may not yet have departed, cleaning may be cancelled, supplies may need replenishing, facilities may be faulty, maintenance needs may have to be communicated, or rework may be required. These events have different causes and responsibilities and cannot all be placed under “slow cleaning.”
To allocate work sensibly among room attendants, look beyond the number of rooms assigned to each person. The head of housekeeping could add several groups of information to the hotel’s existing records: room type and work area; planned and actual cleaning categories; the start and end of the normal cleaning work; waiting time and interruptions; additional tasks and their reasons; supplies and support from other roles; returns and handovers; inspection results and reasons for rework.
Timing is for comparing tasks and identifying obstacles, not for turning every pause an employee takes into grounds for a penalty. Before observation begins, an authorised manager should specify the purpose, scope, person responsible for recording, and how the information will be used. Necessary notice and authorisation should be completed in accordance with the hotel’s personnel policies and applicable requirements. Information that could identify individual guests or employees should not be included in worksheets or public materials. Where an item cannot be timed accurately, it should be left blank with an honest explanation, rather than filled in with a fabricated figure.
Cleaning time is also not the whole shift. Moving between areas, collecting and delivering supplies, waiting to enter rooms, equipment failures and supporting other work may all affect the employee’s workload during the shift. Waiting to enter a room does not necessarily mean that an employee can actually rest. Listing these items separately helps distinguish issues with the cleaning method inside the room from issues with on-site conditions or coordination between roles.
Start with One Actual Shift and a Five-Line Observation Sheet
Hotel Shift Task Observation Sheet
Scope of observation: Date, shift, floor or area, person recording and necessary authorisation. Do not enter guests’ personal information.
Planned tasks: Room types and planned cleaning categories, corresponding number of rooms, and expected conditions for entering the rooms.
Actual process: Actual cleaning categories, the start and end of the work, waiting time and interruptions, and additional tasks and their reasons.
Support and quality: Supplies and assistance from other roles, how irregularities were handled, inspection results, reasons for rework and completion status.
Review and adjustment: Whether similar tasks are appropriately grouped, which tasks must be separated, and which matters need to be escalated for a decision.
The following is a hypothetical completed example. It demonstrates only how the fields connect. It does not represent any real hotel, employee or operating result, and it is not intended to set a workload standard.
Scope of observation: A morning shift on a weekday, covering the same room types on the same floor.
Planned tasks: Before the shift began, one room was scheduled as a stayover cleaning within an established area based on the projected information available at the time.
Actual process: When the room attendant reached the room, the conditions for entering it had not yet been confirmed. The wait and its reason were recorded first. After the front desk confirmed that the guest had departed early and that the room could be entered, the category was changed from stayover to checkout cleaning. The waiting period was therefore recorded separately, rather than as time spent cleaning inside the room.
Support and quality: Supplies were obtained through the existing arrangements for the floor, and the inspection was completed according to the hotel’s current inspection items. The omission identified was reworked and then checked again, with the outcome recorded accurately.
Review and adjustment: After the shift, this last-minute change of category and the wait were included in the review. Before the next assignment of work, the day’s projected checkouts, stayovers and last-minute changes should be checked, together with the person to approach for confirmation when a category changes. Whether adjacent tasks should be grouped differently depends on whether other comparable, normally operating shifts show the same pattern; a weighting should not be inferred from this one room.
In the initial summary, compare only rooms of the same type, the same cleaning category and broadly similar working conditions. If the actual categories or conditions differ, explain the difference first rather than rushing to rank employees. If the sample for a subcategory on a single day is too small, record only the observation. Do not establish a stable weighting in minutes, let alone fill missing data with an average.
The general manager can authorise the head of housekeeping to select an existing shift for observation. Before the first observed shift begins, the work should be allocated using the information already available and the hotel’s current methods, without waiting for the observation sheet to produce results that do not yet exist. The front desk provides information on projected checkouts, stayovers and anything affecting the conditions for room entry. Housekeeping checks the hotel’s service and handover requirements, and engineering explains known matters that may affect cleaning or safety. The assignments preserve existing arrangements for floor familiarity, accountability for quality and coordination between roles.
The first observed shift proceeds under the existing arrangements as described above, with a truthful record of what happens. Guests are not disturbed and additional services are not created simply to increase the sample. The observation continues to use the hotel’s current cleaning and inspection standards and does not create a separate “pilot pass mark.” Safety or quality issues and irregularities that fall outside the established scope of authority must be handled immediately under existing procedures and must not be postponed until after the shift to complete the observation.
After the shift, the head of housekeeping reviews with the relevant roles the differences between planned and actual categories, waiting time and interruptions, support and rework, the actual wrap-up and room-status handovers. Only where the records can explain differences in tasks or conditions should they inform the next assignment of work. If an adjustment is needed, address the identified problems with waiting, supplies or handovers first, rather than mechanically exchanging one checkout for one stayover. An isolated irregularity should be dealt with promptly, but one room cannot provide a weighting for every subsequent shift.
When to Stop and Which Conclusions Not to Draw Prematurely
If an inspection is omitted, necessary rework is left undone, the handover of a room with an irregularity is unclear, or the actual workload exceeds what the existing arrangements can accommodate, the situation should first be corrected under current procedures. Until the issue has been resolved, subsequent arrangements affected by it should be paused. Work should return to an allocation confirmed to be practical, and the cause should be identified. When a room does not yet meet the hotel’s handover requirements, scheduling “optimisation” must not be used to conceal the gap, nor should this automatically make additional rooms available for sale.
A faster shift may involve simpler tasks, rooms in a different condition or more support; a slower shift may involve waiting for guests to vacate, facility-related problems or additional services taking up time. Short-term observation does not automatically demonstrate that staffing can be reduced. Conversely, only where clear differences continue to occur for similar tasks under similar conditions should the working methods, supplies support and training needs be examined further. Recognising that the mix of tasks matters must not be mistaken for saying that people-related factors never matter.
Resort, business, full-service and limited-service hotels provide different services. A hotel experiencing group arrivals, a concentration of checkouts or equipment irregularities should not mechanically apply observations from an ordinary shift. This method addresses only task identification and allocation within existing shifts; it does not replace decisions on staffing levels, revenue or the phased release of rooms during a pre-opening period.
Before the next round of scheduling, select one actual shift and go beyond “how many rooms” to identify which tasks are involved, under what conditions, and who provides support. MarvelBros C&T recommends looking at the work clearly before deciding how to allocate it.
Source: Aguilar-Escobar et al., “Hotel Room Cleaning: Time Study and Analysis of Influential Variables in a Spanish Hotel,” Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management, 2021, 14(3), pp. 645–660. https://doi.org/10.3926/jiem.3441
Does this article relate to your hotel?
Tell us your project stage and the question you find hardest to answer. The article reference will accompany your enquiry.
Ask about this article